9.95Goat Cheese NapoleonCreamy goat cheese, roasted garlic, roasted red peppers, basil pesto and pine nuts layered and served with toasted tuscan bread.
10.95Bacon Cajun ShrimpGulf shrimp wrapped in bacon, cajun spiced and broiled.
11.95Brick SteakTenderloin tips sauteed with garlic and wine, served with garlic bread.
10.95Coconut ShrimpBatter dipped and rolled in coconut, deep fried and served with a spicy marmalade sauce.
10.95Shrimp CocktailWith lemon and cocktail sauce.
Soup of the DayOptions:
Cup (2.95)
, Bowl (3.95)
10.95Crab CakesTwo maryland crab cakes, served with bistro sauce.
10.95Antipasto PlatterItalian meats and cheeses served with a variety of accompaniments. Serves two.
6.95Italian SausageBrick steak sauteed with peppers and onions.
9.95CalamariTender cuts of the steak, lightly breaded and fried with peppers. Remoulade sauce.
5.95Onion RingsHand dipped and deep fried.
5.95Mushrooms or ZucchiniLightly coated and deep fried.Options:
Mushrooms, Zucchini
3.95French Onion Soup Au Gratin
Salads
11.95Citrus Salmon SaladGrilled salmon, mandarin oranges, red pepper, shaved red onion and toasted almonds on mixed greens with mango chardonnay vinaigretteOptions:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry salad, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
12.95Steakhouse SaladGrilled seasoned flatiron steak with red skin potatoes, red onions, blue cheese, crumbled bacon, hard boiled egg and tomatoes. Homemade ranch dressing.Options:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry salad, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
11.95Italian Cobb SaladCrisp lettuce tossed with diced grilled chicken, diced salami, artichoke hearts, olives, tomatoes, red onion, hard boiled egg and crumbled blue cheese. White balsamic viniagrette.Options:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry salad, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
7.95Greek SaladWith feta, beets, artichokes, peppers and veggie trimmings. Anchovies if you like.Options:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry salad, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
7.95Andrea's Chopped SaladA tasty blend of chopped vegetables, lettuces, and crushed flatbread in a balsamic viniagrette.Options:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry salad, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
6.95Sammy's caesar saladWith, romaine, parmesan, housemade croutons and our own Sammy caesar dressing. add your choice of grilled chicken or cajun beef tenderloin tips.Options:
Grilled chicken, Cajun beef, Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry salad, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
7.50Salad and Soupyour choice of a half Sammy caesar, half michigan cherry or a tossed salad with a bowl of soup.Options:
Half Sammy caesar, Half michigan cherry, Tossed, Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry salad, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
Sibley's Luncheon Favorites
14.95Crab CakesA new favorite! Two tender maryland crab cakes with bistro sauce.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
14.95Tilapia FlorentineLemon pepper coated fillet on a bed of sauteed spinach, with citrus beurre blanc.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
15.95WhitefishA fresh lake superior fillet, broiledOptions:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
15.95Smothered SirloinAn 8oz. Strip steak, grilled to your liking and smothered with mushrooms, sauteed onions and swiss cheese.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
14.95Chicken ParmigianaBreaded and fried, then baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella and parmigiana cheese.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
14.95Tenderloin Tips Portabella PortTenderloin tips sauteed with onions, abella mushrooms and marsala demi glace.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
14.95Chicken LeelanauBreast of chicken with dried cherries and walnuts in a marsala cream sauce.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
14.95Chicken PiccanteTender breast medallions sauteed with wine, lemon and a touch of garlic.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
17.95steak SammyA customer favorite! Two medallions of beef tenderloin sauteed with wine, garlic and parsley.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
Pasta Specialties
9.95Pasta with Tomato SauceA smooth meat based tomato sauce with you choice of pasta.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
10.95Fettuccini AlfredoCreamy parmesan sauce over fettuccini.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
11.95Meat Lover's PastaHope you're hungry! penne with meat sauce, meatballs and Italian sausage topped with mozzarella and baked.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
10.95Cheese RavioliPasta pockets filled with three cheeses in our savory tomato sauce.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
9.95Pasta BologneseOur savory tomato sauce with ground beef and your choice of pasta.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
12.95Mediterranean PastaPenne tossed with roasted red peppers, dried tomatoes, spinach, goat cheese, tomatoes, pine nuts, kalamata olives, basil and garlic olive oil.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
12.95Homemade RavioliHand made and filled with meat, served with our savory tomato sauce.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
Sandwiches and Panini
8.95Sibley BurgerOur famous 1/2lb ground sirloin broiled to order and served on a toasted Sibley roll.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
9.95Chicken Piccante SandwichTwo medallions on a Sibley roll with the Piccante sauce for dipping.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
14.95SammyOur own steak Sammy served on a Sibley roll with the Sammy sauce on the side for dipping.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
11.95Perch SandwichFried fillets of lake perch on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
8.95Club SandwichA classic, served on two slices of your bread choice with roasted turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
6.95Tuna Salad SandwichWhite albacore tuna tossed with crunchy celery and mayo, served on your choice of bread.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
8.95Caprese PanniniFresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, and basil pesto, pressed and grilled.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
8.95Turkey Cuban PanniniSliced turkey breast, prosciutto, salami and swiss with mustard, mayo and dill pickle, pressed and grilled.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
8.95Tuscan Chicken PanniniSliced grilled chicken, artichoke hearts, parmesan mayo, mozzarella, roasted red pepper and balsamic onions, pressed and grilled.Options:
Tossed salad (+2.50)
, Side Sammy caesar (+2.50)
Dinner
Appetizers
11.95Crab CakesTwo maryland crab cakes, served with bistro sauce.
7.95Italian Formaggio DipA creamy blend of Italian cheeses and crumbled Italian sausage baked until bubbly, topped with tuscan salsa, served with crunchy pita chips for dipping.
11.95Seared Ahi TunaPepper crusted and seared, served rare with wasabi and balsamic glaze.
12.95EscargotSauteed in garlic bacon butter with scallops and mushroom caps.
9.95Shrimp CocktailWith lemon and cocktail sauce.
6.95Mozzarella CapreseThe traditional salad of fresh mozzarella, vine ripened tomatoes, red onion and basil, white balsamic viniagrette.
10.95Antipasto PlatterItalian meats and cheeses served with a variety of accompaniments. Serves two.
5.95Mushrooms or ZucchiniLightly coated and deep fried.Options:
Mushrooms, Zucchini
8.95Goat Cheese NapoleonCreamy goat cheese, roasted garlic, roasted red peppers, basil pesto and pine nuts layered and served with toasted tuscan bread and olive oil.
7.50Portabella FriesSlices of seasoned portabella mushrooms in a beer batter, fried and served with honey mustard and balsamic syrup.
11.95Coconut ShrimpFour jumbo shrimp batter dipped and rolled in coconut, deep fried and served with a spicy marmalade sauce.
11.95Brick SteakTenderloin tips sauteed with garlic and wine, served with garlic bread.
9.95CalamariTender cuts of the steak, lightly breaded and fried with peppers. Remoulade sauce.
10.95Bacon Cajun ShrimpGulf shrimp wrapped in bacon, cajun spiced and broiled
6.95Italian SausageSauteed with peppers and onions.
5.95Onion RingsHand dipped and deep fried.
3.95French Onion Soup Au Gratin
Sandwiches
8.95Sibley BurgerOur famous 1/2lb ground sirloin broiled to order and served on a toasted Sibley roll.Options:
Fries (+2.00)
, Cup of soup (+2.00)
, Tossed salad, Side caesar
9.95Chicken Piccante SandwichTwo medallions on a Sibley roll with the Piccante sauce for dipping.Options:
Fries (+2.00)
, Cup of soup (+2.00)
, Tossed salad, Side caesar
13.95Sammy IiiOur own steak Sammy served on a Sibley roll with the Sammy sauce on the side for dipping.Options:
Fries (+2.00)
, Cup of soup (+2.00)
, Tossed salad, Side caesar
11.95Perch SandwichFried fillets of lake perch on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce.Options:
Fries (+2.00)
, Cup of soup (+2.00)
, Tossed salad, Side caesar
Salads
12.95Steakhouse SaladGrilled seasoned flatiron steak with red skin potatoes, red onions, blue cheese, crumbled bacon, hard boiled egg and tomatoes. Homemade ranch dressing.Options:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
12.95Citrus Salmon SaladGrilled salmon, mandarin oranges, red pepper, shaved red onion and toasted almonds on mixed greens with mango chardonnay vinaigretteOptions:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
7.95Andrea's Chopped SaladA tasty blend of chopped vegetables, lettuces, and crushed flatbread in a balsamic viniagrette.Options:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
12.95Italian Cobb SaladCrisp lettuce tossed with diced grilled chicken, diced salami, artichoke hearts, olives, tomatoes, red onion, hard boiled egg and crumbled blue cheese. White balsamic viniagrette.Options:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
7.95Michigan Cherry SaladDried michigan cherries, walnuts, bleu cheese, romaine lettuce and raspberry vinaigrette. With or withour grilled chicken.Options:
With grilled chicken, Withour grilled chicken, Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
6.95Sammy's Caesar SaladWith romaine, parmesan, housemade croutons and our own Sammy caesar dressing.Options:
Andrea's chopped, Michigan cherry, Grilled chicken breast (+3.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+5.00)
, Grilled shrimp (+7.00)
Pasta Specialties
19.95Scallops and Shrimp San MarcoScallops and shrimp sauteed with roma tomatoes, artichokes, and capers. Served over fettuccini.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
13.95Fettuccini AlfredoCreamy parmesan sauce over fettuccini.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
15.95Homemade RavioliHand made and filled with meat, served with our savory tomato sauce.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
15.95Sachettini GorgonzolaCheese filled pasta purses, tossed in a creamy alfredo sauce with gorgonzola cheese, spinach and grilled chicken.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
14.95Meat Lover's PastaHope you're hungry! penne with meat sauce, meatballs and Italian sausage topped with mozzarella and baked.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
15.95Mediterranean PastaPenne tossed with roasted red peppers, dried tomatoes, spinach, goat cheese, tomatoes, pine nuts, kalamata olives basil and garlic olive oil.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
15.95Eggplant ParmigianaTender eggplant baked with two cheeses and served with spaghetti.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
12.95Pasta BologneseOur savory tomato sauce with ground beef and your choice of pasta.Options:
Soup, Salad, Meatballs (+3.00)
, Italian sausage (+3.00)
, Grilled chicken (+3.00)
Ssteaks and Chops
19.95Gorgonzola Tenderloin MedallionsTwin medallions of beef tenderloin, seasoned and grilled, topped with gorgonzola butter, served with cabernet demi glace.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
17.95Tenderloin Tips PortabellaTenderloin tips sauteed with onions, portabella mushrooms and marsala demi glace.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
21.9512Oz. DelmonicoCut from the center of the ribeye, char grilled to your liking.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
28.95RibeyeAn 18oz. Bone in center cut ribeye, char grilled.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
26.95New York StripA 14 ounce choice center cut sirloin.Options:
Soup, Salad, Potato, Pasta, Vegetable
3.95Grilled ZucchiniSliced and brushed with olive oil then grilled.
4.95Potatoes MikesellGolden fried potato slices topped with crumbled bleu cheese and beef jus, baked until bubbly.
4.50Sauteed Hot Peppers
Family Style Dinners
Antipasti
Bruschetta Toasted tuscan bread with roma tomatoes, mozzarella and basil
Salad
Mixed GreensWith our balsamic viniagrette
Entree Selections
Italian Sausage With peppers and onions.
Brick Steak Tenderloin tips sauteed in wine, garlic and parsley.
Chicken Piccante Breast medallions sauteed with a lemon wine sauce.
Chicken Scaloppine Sauteed in a tomato mushroom wine sauce.
Chicken Tosca Breast medallions in a parmigiana and egg batter, sauteed.
Grilled Salmon With lemon garlic herb butter.
Whitefish Broiled.
Pasta
Mostaccioli with Tomato Sauce
Spaghetti with Garlic and Oil
Fettuccini Alfredo
Fettuccini with Pesto Cream
Steak Sammy Medallions of beef tenderloin sauteed with wine, garlic and parsley.
Veal Scaloppine With a tomato mushroom sauce.
Veal Marsala With a portabella marsala cream sauce
Sauteed Shrimp (Three per person) with sun-dried tomatoes, garlic and herbs.
Dessert
SpumoniIce cream or sherbetOptions:
Ice cream, Sherbet
Meals to Go
Entrees
39.95Chicken ParmigianaTender breast of chicken layered with tomato sauce and mozzarella and parmigiana cheese.Options:
With tossed, Caesar salad, Spaghetti, Red skins
39.95Chicken PiccanteMedallions of tender breast meat sauteed with white wine and lemon juice.Options:
With tossed, Caesar salad, Spaghetti, Red skins
39.95Chicken LeelanauChicken breast medallions sauteed with dried cherries and walnuts in a marsala cream sauce.Options:
With tossed, Caesar salad, Spaghetti, Red skins
39.95Sonoma ChickenChicken breast, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers and capers sauteed with lemon wine sauce.Options:
With tossed, Caesar salad, Spaghetti, Red skins
49.95Tenderloin of Beef Tips PortobelloTenderloin tips sauteed with portobello mushrooms, onions and our marsala demi glace.Options:
With tossed, Caesar salad, Spaghetti, Red skins
59.95Steak SammyMedallions of beef tenderloin sauteed with wine and garlic. 8 MedallionsOptions:
With tossed, Caesar salad, Spaghetti, Red skins
Pastas
39.95Meat Lover's PastaPenne tossed with meat sauce, Italian sausage, meatballs and more meat sauce. baked with mozzarella.Options:
Tossed, Caesar
39.95Chicken CarciofiBreast of chicken, artichoke hearts and mushrooms with penne in a creamy tomato sauce.Options:
Tossed, Caesar
10.00Chicken Breast or Italian SausageGrilled - add to any of the below pasta dinnersOptions:
Chicken breast, Italian sausage, Tossed, Caesar
39.95Mediterranean PastaPenne tossed with spinach, goat cheese, roasted red peppers, kalamata olives, dried tomatoes, diced tomatoes, basil and garlic olive oil.Options:
Tossed, Caesar
39.95Cheese RavioliTender pasta pockets filled with three cheeses with tomato sauceOptions:
Tossed, Caesar
29.95Spaghetti or MostaccioliWith tomato or meat sauceOptions:
Spaghetti, Mostaccioli, Tomato, Meat sauce, Tossed, Caesar
Salads for a Crowd
13.95Sammy's Caesar SaladA traditional caesar saladOptions:
Grilled chicken breast (+10.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+15.00)
15.95Michgan Cherry SaladDried michigan cherries, walnuts and blue cheese atop romaine lettuce with raspberry vinaigrette.Options:
Grilled chicken breast (+10.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+15.00)
15.95Andrea's Chopped SaladA tasty blend of chopped vegetables, crushed flatbread and chopped lettuces with our white balsamic vinaigretteOptions:
Grilled chicken breast (+10.00)
, Cajun tenderloin tips (+15.00)
Soups, Sauces and Dressings
Minestrone or Soup Du JourOptions:
Pt (N/a)
, Qt (7.00)
Tomato SauceOptions:
Pt (N/a)
, Qt (7.00)
Gallon of Tomato SauceOptions:
Pt (N/a)
, Qt (20.00)